Monday, May 26, 2008

Why Democracy can be good or bad.

I think that representative democracy can be good or bad depending on the circumstances and the types.

Democracy means that decisions are made by voting. This voting can be representative, where one person votes for many people, or individual, where each votes for himself. Lastly, there is a sort of consensual democracy, where discussion is held and everyone comes to a consensus.

To begin, I think that consensual democracy is not practical. For example, it is already not easy to get a group of people to come to a consensus regarding a matter of heated discussion, what more for millions of people?

Individual democracy, where everyone votes for the one option, is an accurate measurement of the people's opinions, however, not everyone may turn up on the voting day, and voting results may be skewed and affected by bias and corruption.

Representative democracy gives each constituency a representative to argue for their opinions and the representative is selected from amongst the people to advocate their views. In this manner, it is the people's choices that are made, as the representative ought to know what the people want.

However, the disadvantage, as mentioned by Shien Hian, is that during elections, some people vote for candidates who are good looking, charismatic, but may not necessarily be the best to represent them.

I think that though democracy is a good way to find out people's views through voting, not much more can be done to advocate these views. If there is a unanimous vote, which is highly unlikely, then all's well that ends well.

However, the problem is that almost all the time, there is a majority, and inevitably a minority. The views of the minority, must still be able to be expressed and debated over. Only in this manner will democracy be a good ruling system.

Otherwise, if the minority views are overrun, then it is not a democracy, but rather a tyranny.